Zum Inhalt springen
Capital allocation

Developer due diligence: the 10 checkpoints where developers fail (2026)

By Samuel Obermeier·Updated 2026·12 min read·Capital allocation
Explained on video

Real estate due diligence: how to check a developer’s track record properly

How to check a developer’s track record properly: which evidence counts, which figures are embellished and how to tell.

Watch on YouTube
More videos on the YouTube channel

The video only loads from YouTube after you click. No investment advice, no return promises.

01

Why developers fail on evidence, not on interest

Most rejections of developers are caused not by the interest rate. They come from documents that are missing, a liability chain that leads nowhere, and a calculation whose buffer is used up before the first excavator arrives.

This list is therefore written from the opposite direction: not “what does the developer promise” but “what can be evidenced”. Each point names the question, the document that answers it and the warning sign at which the review ends. For capital providers it is a working document. For developers it is a mirror: anyone who answers all ten points cleanly in advance shortens their development finance considerably, because the follow-up questions on which most processes get stuck fall away.

02

Part I: Who is behind the project

Checkpoint 1: Who is actually liable, and with what?

Almost every project runs through its own property company (a project-specific special purpose vehicle). That is usual and not a warning sign in itself. What matters is whether there is substance behind this company or only a name.

  • Question: Who is the contracting party, who is the shareholder, and is the parent company jointly liable, or does the chain end at a GmbH (German limited liability company) with EUR 25,000 of share capital?
  • Evidence: Current commercial register extract plus shareholder list via the company register (Unternehmensregister) 1; where joint liability is promised, the comfort letter (Patronatserklärung) or surety bond in its exact wording, not as a promise in conversation.
  • Warning sign: The property company was founded a few weeks before the capital request, the parent company is not jointly liable, and the ownership chain runs through several tiers abroad.

Checkpoint 2: Is the track record documented or merely told?

“We have realised over EUR 400 million of project volume” is not a data point but a phrasing. It only becomes reliable when it can be broken down into individual, completed projects.

  • Question: Which projects were completed and handed over by exactly this company and this managing director, not “accompanied”, not “co-developed”?
  • Evidence: Project list with address, year of completion and number of units, checkable by sampling against the commercial register and land register. In addition two references that may be called.
  • Warning sign: The track record belongs to another company, a former employer or a partner who is not involved in the current project. Borrowed history is the most frequent finding of all.

Checkpoint 3: What do the annual financial statements say?

Corporations must publish their annual financial statements (§ 325 HGB, German Commercial Code) 3. Anyone who fails to do so or skips years is already making a statement.

  • Question: What are the equity ratio, loss carry-forwards and liabilities, and how have they developed over three years?
  • Evidence: Federal Gazette (Bundesanzeiger) for the published financial statements 2; for the current year an up-to-date management report (BWA) with trial balance.
  • Warning sign: Publication is missing or several years behind; equity is negative and carried solely by shareholder loans, which are themselves subordinated in a worst case.

Checkpoint 4: Is anything pending against the parties involved?

This point takes twenty minutes and is skipped most often.

  • Question: Are there ongoing or concluded insolvency proceedings, enforcement entries or conspicuous company dissolutions at the company, its shareholders or its managing director?
  • Evidence: Federal insolvency announcements 4, the debtor register of the competent enforcement court, a credit report on the company and on the persons acting.
  • Warning sign: A series of dissolved property companies with the same persons acting. Individual failed projects happen; a pattern is something else. What such a pattern looks like in practice is shown in the anatomy of a developer insolvency.
03

Part II: Whether the project is viable

Checkpoint 5: How far has planning law really progressed?

Between “preliminary building enquiry answered positively” and “final and binding building permit” there are, if in doubt, twelve months and the entire calculation.

  • Question: Is there a building permit, has the objection period expired, and which conditions are attached: parking space levy, social housing obligation, species protection, contaminated land?
  • Evidence: The permit decision in full including ancillary provisions. Not the summary in the brochure, but the decision itself.
  • Warning sign: The calculation assumes a floor area that has not yet been approved. The schedule starts with a construction start for which the permit is yet to come. In this phase only a short bridge financing is viable, not construction-phase financing.

Checkpoint 6: What is in the land register, in all three sections?

Everyone reads Section III. The expensive surprises are in Section II.

  • Question: Which easements, rights of way, pre-emption rights, heritable building rights or reconveyance priority notices encumber the plot, and which land charges (Grundschulden) rank in which order?
  • Evidence: Current land register extract, not older than three months, in full length. Where contamination is suspected, additionally the information from the register of contaminated sites.
  • Warning sign: The extract is supplied only in part, redacted or in an outdated version. An easement restricts exactly the area on which building is planned.

Checkpoint 7: Does the calculation withstand a counter-calculation?

The calculation is the point where a review differs from passing a deal on. It does not have to be optimistic, it has to be recalculable.

  • Question: Are construction costs per square metre, timeline, financing costs and sales costs shown separately, and how much buffer remains if construction costs rise by ten percent and sales take six months longer?
  • Evidence: Complete calculation as a spreadsheet with formulas, not as a PDF extract; plus the quotes or cost estimates on which the construction costs are based.
  • Warning sign: A single scenario without sensitivity. Sales prices well above local comparables without the difference being justified. Financing costs that include only the nominal interest rate, not fees and bullet maturity. What subordinated capital really costs is worked out by the mezzanine cost calculator.
04

Part III: How the capital is structured

Checkpoint 8: Where exactly does the money stand in the order of ranking?

In a worst case the ranking question decides everything else. It must be answered in writing and unambiguously.

  • Question: First-ranking, second-ranking or subordinated? Is there a qualified subordination (qualifizierter Rangrücktritt), and has its effect been explained: that in an insolvency all other creditors are served first 56?
  • Evidence: The loan agreement in draft, the certificate of ranking from the financing bank and Section III of the land register with the rights already entered.
  • Warning sign: A subordinated loan is advertised as “secured by a land charge”. Both at once is not possible: anyone who is subordinated stands behind the land charge creditors. More on this in Understanding subordinated loans and Which collateral really holds value.

Checkpoint 9: Where does the money come back from?

Every repayment has exactly one source. If it cannot be named, it does not yet exist.

  • Question: Does the exit run through individual sales, a bulk sale or follow-on financing, and what is already evidenced: notarised purchase contracts, a term sheet, a letter of intent or only an expectation?
  • Evidence: Pre-sales list distinguishing between notarised contracts and mere reservations; for a bulk sale the buyer’s term sheet; for follow-on financing the bank’s indication.
  • Warning sign: Reservations are counted as pre-sales. A reservation is legally almost worthless; the Federal Court of Justice has declared reservation fees in general terms and conditions invalid 7.

Checkpoint 10: Who controls where the money goes?

The point asked least often and the most important in a worst case.

  • Question: Is the capital paid out earmarked, is there a control of the use of funds by an independent third party, and are the payouts tied to construction progress?
  • Evidence: Agreement on control of the use of funds, payout plan by stage of construction (analogous to the instalments under § 3 MaBV, the German developer escrow and instalment regulation) 8, reporting duties with deadline and recipient.
  • Warning sign: The capital is paid out in one sum to an account of the company, without earmarking and without control. Reporting duties are agreed, but without a deadline and without consequence for a breach.
05

The 10 checkpoints at a glance

No.CheckpointDecisive evidenceTypical warning sign
1Liability chainCommercial register, shareholder list, comfort letter in exact wordingNewly founded property GmbH without joint liability
2Track recordProject list with address and year, referencesBorrowed history of other companies
3Annual financial statementsFederal Gazette, current BWAPublication behind, negative equity
4RegistersInsolvency announcements, debtor registerSeries of dissolved property companies
5Planning lawPermit decision with ancillary provisionsCalculated area not yet approved
6Land registerComplete extract, max. 3 months oldSection II encumbers the building area
7CalculationSpreadsheet with formulas, cost quotesNo scenario with higher costs
8RankingDraft contract, certificate of ranking“Subordinated and secured by a land charge”
9ExitNotarised contracts, term sheetReservations counted as pre-sales
10Use of fundsControl agreement, payout planPayout in one sum without earmarking
Scroll table sideways
06

The three questions when time is short

  1. Show me the complete commercial register extract and the shareholder list of the contracting party.
  2. Show me the building permit with all ancillary provisions.
  3. Show me the calculation as a spreadsheet and run it with ten percent higher costs.

Anyone who delivers all three within a week works properly. Anyone who evades all three has already answered the review.

07

What developers should make of this

The same list works in the other direction. Developers looking for mezzanine capital, a whole loan or project financing should bundle the ten pieces of evidence in a data room before the first capital provider asks. Which documents are expected in which form is set out in What belongs in a capital provider memorandum. Anyone who wants to know whether their own project passes the review can have it assessed free of charge in advance.

Frequently asked questions

Sources

  1. [1][1] Unternehmensregister: commercial register and shareholder lists https://www.unternehmensregister.de
  2. [2][2] Bundesanzeiger: published annual financial statements https://www.bundesanzeiger.de
  3. [3][3] § 325 HGB: disclosure https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/hgb/__325.html
  4. [4][4] Insolvency announcements of the Federal Republic https://www.insolvenzbekanntmachungen.de
  5. [5][5] § 39 InsO: subordinated insolvency creditors https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/inso/__39.html
  6. [6][6] § 19 InsO: over-indebtedness, qualified subordination https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/inso/__19.html
  7. [7][7] BGH, judgment of 20.04.2023, I ZR 113/22: reservation fees in general terms and conditions invalid https://www.bundesgerichtshof.de
  8. [8][8] § 3 MaBV: instalment payments for developers https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/mabv/__3.html
  9. [9][9] § 650u BGB: developer contract https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/bgb/__650u.html
SO
Samuel ObermeierObermeier Capital, Munich

Reviews projects before they are presented to capital providers, and capital requests before family offices and funds start their own review. What does not stand up does not go further.

More about Samuel Obermeier
Channels

Does your project pass the ten points?

Submit your project. Within 24 hours on working days you will know whether it can be financed, with which structure and which evidence is still missing. The initial assessment is free.

Request an initial assessment
Document to take away

The ten checkpoints as a PDF

Seven pages, structured by question, evidence and warning sign, to print and tick off when you review your next project.

What is inside

  • Chain of liability, track record, annual accounts and register checks
  • Building rights, land register and the buffer test for every calculation
  • Ranking, exit and control of the use of funds
  • For every point: the question, the document, the warning sign
PDF · 7 pages · free

Unlock the document

We use your details solely to provide you with the document and to contact you about it.