Zum Inhalt springen
Project capital

Guarantees in the development business

By Samuel Obermeier·As of August 2026·11 min read·Project capital
01

Why guarantees appear in no calculation and still hurt

A guarantee costs no equity. No money flows, nothing appears in the cost statement, and that is why it does not even show up in many project calculations. What it uses up instead is credit line: every guarantee issued occupies part of the guarantee line at the bank, and this line is finite.

The bottleneck rarely shows at the first project. It shows at the third, running in parallel, when the warranty guarantees from project one are still open, project two ties up the completion security and the bank signals for project three that the line is exhausted. From then on the guarantee question is a financing question.

02

First: the security under § 7 MaBV

The Makler- und Bauträgerverordnung (MaBV, German developer escrow and instalment regulation) allows two ways to get at buyers’ money: either by construction progress through the instalment schedule of § 3 MaBV, or against security under § 7 MaBV. Anyone who provides the security is exempt from the obligations of § 3 para. 1 and 2 MaBV and can design the payment plan more freely 1.

The price is in the same section: the security must be maintained until the conditions of § 3 para. 1 MaBV are met and the contract object is fully completed 1. It therefore runs across the entire construction period and ties up the guarantee line for exactly that long.

Who may act as guarantor is narrowly regulated: only public-law corporations, credit institutions authorised to do business in Germany and insurance undertakings with a licence to operate guarantee insurance. The declaration must contain the waiver of the defence of prior recourse (§ 2 para. 2 MaBV) 2. A guarantee from the parent company does not meet this requirement.

03

Second: the completion security of five percent

In the consumer construction contract, security for timely completion of the work without material defects, amounting to five percent of the agreed total remuneration, must be provided to the consumer at the first instalment payment (§ 650m para. 2 BGB) 3. This is not a negotiating point but law.

Less well known is the second sentence of the same provision: if the remuneration claim increases by more than ten percent through an instruction from the consumer under §§ 650b and 650c BGB or through other changes, a further security of five percent of the additional remuneration claim must be provided at the next instalment payment 3. Special requests therefore raise not only the price but also the guarantee requirement.

04

Third: the warranty security

The warranty guarantee is not prescribed by law. It is agreed by contract, as a rule by the buyer or by the property developer towards its subcontractors. Economically it is the most unpleasant of the four because it runs longest: across the entire warranty period, that is, years after completion.

For guarantee line planning this means: a project ties up the line not until handover but until the end of the warranty. Anyone who completes three projects at five-year intervals never has more than one in the line. Anyone who completes three in parallel ends up with all three in it at the same time.

05

Fourth: the contractor’s security, which runs against you

You provide the first three. The fourth is demanded of you by someone else: the contractor can demand security from the customer for the agreed and not yet paid remuneration, including ancillary claims, which are to be assumed at ten percent of the remuneration claim to be secured (§ 650f para. 1 BGB) 4.

In tense times this right is exercised much more often: a general contractor who doubts the creditworthiness of its client demands security before building on. Anyone who has already exhausted the guarantee line then comes to a standstill. This is one of the ways in which a project tips over without anything being wrong with the project itself.

06

The four guarantees compared

GuaranteeBasisWho provides itTermTypical amount
Security instead of instalment schedule§ 7 MaBVProperty developer for the buyeruntil full completionAmount of the sums accepted
Completion security§ 650m para. 2 BGBProperty developer for the consumeruntil acceptance5 percent of total remuneration
Warranty securityContractProperty developer or subcontractorover the warranty periodagreed by contract
Contractor’s security§ 650f BGBCustomer for the contractoruntil paymentRemuneration plus 10 percent ancillary claims
Contract performance securityContractSubcontractor for the property developeruntil acceptanceagreed by contract
Scroll table sideways
07

What a guarantee costs

The bank charges a guarantee commission, usually as a percentage of the guaranteed amount per year. There are no reliable market figures for it. The rate depends on creditworthiness, collateral and house bank relationship and is negotiated individually. That is why we name no range here.

Something can still be calculated, and it is the more important part: the duration times the amount. A five percent security on a project with EUR 12 million of remuneration is EUR 600,000 that sit in the line for the entire construction period. If warranty guarantees from a previous project are added, the line is full faster than the calculation suggests.

08

When the guarantee line is the bottleneck

A full guarantee line looks like a bank topic but acts like an equity gap: the project stands still although the calculation carries. The routes are the same as for any other gap: provide additional collateral, broaden the bank relationship or add capital that relieves the line. What the routes cost is in the article on closing the equity gap.

And because the instalment schedule of § 3 MaBV is the alternative to the security under § 7 MaBV, it is worth looking at both sides of the same decision: how the instalment schedule works and what stalling unit sales do to it is in the article on instalments and guarantees under the MaBV.

09

The checklist before the project starts

  1. How high is the free guarantee line today, not the committed one, the free one?
  2. Which guarantees from completed projects are still running, and until when?
  3. Is the work done under the instalment schedule (§ 3 MaBV) or against security (§ 7 MaBV)?
  4. Is the intended guarantor permissible at all under § 2 para. 2 MaBV?
  5. Does the guarantee declaration contain the waiver of the defence of prior recourse?
  6. Is five percent completion security planned for all consumer contracts?
  7. Is the top-up for special requests above ten percent included in the calculation?
  8. Which warranty securities do the buyer contracts require, and how long do they run?
  9. What happens if a general contractor demands security under § 650f BGB?
  10. Is it regulated when a guarantee is returned, and who reclaims it?

Frequently asked questions

Sources

  1. [1]§ 7 MaBV: exemption provision: security instead of instalment schedule https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/gewo_34cdv/__7.html
  2. [2]§ 2 MaBV: security and permissible guarantors https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/gewo_34cdv/__2.html
  3. [3]§ 650m BGB: instalment payments and security in the consumer construction contract https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/bgb/__650m.html
  4. [4]§ 650f BGB: contractor’s security https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/bgb/__650f.html
  5. [5]§ 3 MaBV: special security obligations for property developers, instalment schedule https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/gewo_34cdv/__3.html
  6. [6]§ 765 BGB: typical contractual duties under a guarantee https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/bgb/__765.html
  7. [7]§ 771 BGB: defence of prior recourse https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/bgb/__771.html
  8. [8]§ 650u BGB: developer contract, applicable law https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/bgb/__650u.html
SO
Samuel ObermeierObermeier Capital, Munich

Regularly sees projects that hang not on equity but on the guarantee line, and obtains mezzanine capital on mandate for developers.

More about Samuel Obermeier
Channels

When it is not the equity that is missing but the line.

We review calculation, ranking and exit, and tell you beforehand whether a supplement carries or whether the project jams somewhere else.

View the mezzanine mandate