The video only loads from YouTube after you click. No investment advice, no return promises.
01
Why enquiries end in silence
A capital provider rarely says no. He simply stops answering. This is regularly read as lack of interest in the project, but is usually something else: he cannot make a decision with what is in front of him, and he goes to the effort of requesting the missing details one by one only for projects that have already convinced him.
This is not malice but division of labour. Anyone who lends capital institutionally sees more enquiries a month than he can review. The first sorting therefore does not run on the quality of the project but on how reviewable the document is. Whoever submits completely gets into the review. Whoever submits incompletely goes on the pile.
02
First: a calculation that can be recalculated
A capital provider’s first look is not at the return but at whether he can recalculate the return. A figure without the assumptions behind it is worthless, because it cannot be checked. Disclose the assumptions, including the uncomfortable ones.
Total investment costs, broken down into land, construction costs, ancillary construction costs, financing costs and contingency
Expected proceeds per unit or per square metre, stating what the assumption rests on
The complete capital structure: equity, senior, subordinated, vendor loan, each with amount, interest and maturity
A timeline with cash outflow and cash inflow, not just start and end dates
At least one calculation in which something goes wrong: higher construction costs, lower proceeds, longer marketing
The last point is where experienced submissions differ from inexperienced ones. Anyone who calculates only the success case signals either that they do not know the risks or that they do not want to show them. Both lead to the same reaction. How the cost of capital itself enters the calculation is covered in the article what mezzanine capital really costs.
03
Second: rank and collateral, and what of it holds
No capital provider decides on a participation without knowing where he stands in the ranking. In insolvency, subordinated claims are served under § 39 InsO only after all other creditors 1; in a foreclosure auction § 10 ZVG determines the order of the rank classes 2. These two provisions decide in the worst case whether collateral that has been promised is worth anything.
Land register extract, current, with all sections and the status of the encumbrances
Which land charge (Grundschuld) is registered or is to be registered, at what amount and at which rank position
What other collateral is offered: surety, pledge of company shares, assignment of purchase price claims, letter of comfort
Whether and in what form the senior bank has consented to a subordinated tranche
Which enforcement rights actually exist in the worst case, and from when
The most common mistake here is confusing contractual subordination with land register subordination. Both sound the same and work completely differently. The mechanics are set out in detail in the article Understanding subordinated loans.
04
Third: how the capital provider gets out again
Capital does not go into a project because the entry is attractive but because the exit looks robust. The exit is therefore not a side point at the end of the document but belongs at the front.
From which source repayment comes: individual sales, bulk sale, refinancing as a portfolio holding or sale of the project company
What share of the units must be sold at the time of repayment for the calculation to work
What happens if this share is not reached: extension option, follow-on financing, forced sale
Which marketing period is assumed and what the assumption rests on
For projects repaid through individual sales, the assumed marketing period is the most sensitive assumption in the whole calculation. Why it is almost always set too short is covered in the article on time to sell.
05
Fourth: permit and contract status
A project is as advanced as its permits reach, not as its presentation promises. For capital providers the legal status is the basis of any timetable, and with interest-bearing capital time is directly money.
Status of the building permit: granted, applied for, in prospect or not yet submitted
Securing the land: ownership, priority notice for conveyance (Auflassungsvormerkung), notarial purchase contract under § 311b BGB 6 or only a declaration of intent
For developer projects (Bauträger): the licence under § 34c GewO (German trade licence) 7 and the classification of the contract under § 650u BGB 5
The payment plan towards buyers and its compatibility with the instalment scale of § 3 MaBV (German developer escrow and instalment regulation) 3
Whether a surety under § 7 MaBV 4 is provided and who provides it
The second to last point in particular is underestimated. A payment plan that deviates from the regulation to the buyer’s detriment can be invalid, and then the entire purchase price falls due only on acceptance. For a capital provider this shifts the cash inflow by months. The details are in the article on instalments and sureties under the MaBV.
06
Fifth: the people behind the project
In the end nobody finances a plot of land but the ability of people to carry a project through difficulties. This part is regularly kept too thin in German documents, out of a reticence that is not understood internationally.
Shareholder structure of the project company, including beneficial owners
Completed projects with order of magnitude, period and result, anonymised if desired
Who in the team is responsible for what, in particular for site management and sales
Whether there were projects that did not run as planned, and how they were handled
Current annual accounts or management accounts of the supporting company
07
The checklist before sending
Go through the document before you release it, and answer each question with a page number. Where you cannot name one, something is missing.
Can an outsider recalculate the total investment costs without asking?
Is the complete capital structure with amounts, interest and maturities in one place?
Is at least one unfavourable course worked through?
Is it clear at which rank position the capital requested stands?
Is a current land register extract attached?
Is the permit status named unambiguously, without flattering wording?
Is the securing of the land evidenced and not merely asserted?
Is it stated from which source repayment comes and when?
Is the assumed marketing period justified?
Are the people involved named with verifiable experience?
Does every figure state where it comes from?
Is there a contact who can explain the calculation themselves?
08
What you had better leave out
Some things do more harm than good, because they make the review harder or raise legal questions that nobody needs.
Return promises and wording that claims certainty or the absence of risk
Visualisations without a statement of whether they show the permitted state
Market figures without a source and without a reference date
Comparisons with other people’s projects in which you were not involved
A return as a single figure, without the assumptions behind it
09
The most common mistake is timing
Most enquiries come too late. Capital is sought when the gap is already open and the time pressure is visible. Exactly then the negotiating position worsens, and exactly then there is no time to build a proper document.
The reverse is sensible: the document is ready before it is needed. How a capital raising process runs over time and which deadlines are realistic is covered in the article on the process of a capital placement.