MaBV in practice: instalments, guarantee and the traps in the payment plan
Why the MaBV decides your liquidity
Most property developers treat the Makler- und Bauträgerverordnung as a notary topic, something that is in the contract and is handled by the notary. That is an expensive mistake. The MaBV determines when you see money and in which steps. It is therefore not the legal packaging of your financing but its pacemaker.
In practice this means: your liquidity plan cannot be calculated freely. It is the sum of units sold times the statutory instalment schedule times actual construction progress. If one of the three factors fails, the instalment fails, and the bank still has its debt service.
The legal chain: from the BGB into the regulation
Anyone who wants to understand why the schedule is mandatory has to lay three provisions end to end. This chain is skipped in most accounts, and that is exactly why the mistake persists that the payment plan can be agreed freely.
- § 650u BGB (German Civil Code) defines the developer contract: construction or conversion of a house or comparable structure, combined with the obligation to transfer ownership of the land or to create a heritable building right. Contract law for work applies to the construction work, sale law to the transfer of ownership 1.
- § 650v BGB provides: the contractor can demand instalment payments only to the extent that they are agreed in accordance with a regulation under Article 244 EGBGB 2.
- This regulation is the MaBV. The instalment schedule of § 3 para. 2 MaBV is therefore not a recommendation but the only permissible framework for instalment payments in the developer contract 3.
The four conditions before the first euro may flow
§ 3 para. 1 MaBV permits the acceptance of assets only when four things are present at the same time 3. If one is missing, the instalment is not due, even if construction is well advanced.
- The contract is legally effective and the required approvals are in place.
- The priority notice of conveyance (Auflassungsvormerkung) securing the claim to transfer of ownership is registered in the land register.
- Release from prior encumbrances is assured: the buyer must therefore know that the land charges of your financing bank do not affect them, even if the project fails.
- The building permit is in place, or the right to build is confirmed accordingly.
In practice, point three is the bottleneck. The bank’s release declaration comes late, needs negotiation and depends on the question of what applies if the project fails. Anyone who only initiates it once the first buyers have signed loses weeks, and exactly the weeks in which the first instalment should have flowed.
The instalment schedule: thirteen rates, at most seven instalments
§ 3 para. 2 MaBV permits acceptance in at most seven partial amounts. They are formed from thirteen percentage rates that the regulation assigns to individual construction stages. You may combine rates to arrive at seven instalments, but not bring them forward 3.
| Construction stage | Share of purchase price |
|---|---|
| After start of earthworks | 30 % (20 % for a heritable building right) |
| After completion of the shell, including carpentry | 40 % |
| Completion of roof surfaces and gutters | 8 % |
| Rough installation of heating systems | 3 % |
| Rough installation of sanitary systems | 3 % |
| Rough installation of electrical systems | 3 % |
| Installation of windows including glazing | 10 % |
| Interior plaster, excluding touch-up plastering | 6 % |
| Screed | 3 % |
| Tiling work in sanitary areas | 4 % |
| After readiness for occupation and against handover of possession | 12 % |
| Facade work | 3 % |
| After full completion | 5 % |
Two observations from calculation practice. First: seventy percent of the purchase price hangs on the first two items. Anyone who does not get the shell finished on time does not have a scheduling problem but a liquidity problem. Second: the last five percent comes only after full completion, and that is exactly where the buyer’s longest lever sits in a defects dispute.
If a performance does not occur, the associated rate is distributed proportionately across the remaining instalments. This is not discretion but a rule of arithmetic.
What happens if the payment plan deviates
This is the risk that is regularly underestimated in draft contracts. If the agreed payment plan deviates from the regulation to the buyer’s detriment, it is not only the individual clause that is invalid: the plan as a whole can fall. The statutory fallback rule then takes its place, under which the remuneration falls due only on acceptance.
Way out one: the guarantee under § 7 para. 1
§ 7 para. 1 MaBV exempts from the obligations of §§ 2 to 6 if the property developer provides security for all of the client’s claims to refund or payout. In practice this is a bank guarantee. The security must be maintained until the conditions are met and the contract object is fully completed 5.
Economically this is an exchange: you buy freedom in the payment plan against a guarantee commission and a charge on your credit line. Whether that pays off depends on how much earlier the money flows as a result, and what the alternative costs. This can be calculated against the cost of mezzanine: The cost of mezzanine capital.
- Who may give the guarantee. § 2 MaBV permits guarantees from public-law corporations, credit institutions or authorised insurance undertakings with their seat in Germany; alternatively a suitable insurance can be considered that directly entitles the client even in the event of the trader’s insolvency 6.
- The security ties up your line. A guarantee line is a credit line. Anyone who uses it up for the MaBV guarantee no longer has it for the completion guarantee towards the institutional buyer.
- It runs longer than planned. Until full completion means: including the stragglers and the remedying of defects.
Way out two: the merchant’s waiver under § 7 para. 2
The second way out does not apply to consumers but only to certain buyers. The obligations fall away if the client is a legal person under public law, a special fund under public law or a merchant registered in the commercial or cooperative register and waives the application in a separate deed 5.
The entire feasibility of institutional pre-sales hangs on this. Anyone who offers a fund forward funding is not only selling a property but presupposes that this buyer can waive. Two points for preparation: the waiver belongs in a separate deed, not in a clause in the purchase contract, and the merchant status has to be evidenced, usually by a register extract.
Why stalling unit sales tear the instalment chain apart
Now the part that is missing from legal accounts because it is commercial. The instalment schedule applies per purchase contract. Your project liquidity is therefore the sum of many parallel schedules, and each one hangs on a single buyer.
Construction progresses for all units at the same time. Costs arise for all of them at the same time. But income arises only for the units sold. Every unsold unit is therefore not lost profit at the end but a missing instalment in every single construction stage.
- A fallen-through sale costs twice. The contract falls away, but construction is already at the point where the next instalment would have been due. The new buyer joins later, and the construction stages already reached are then paid in a lump, but later. Calculate it in the fallen-through sales cost calculator.
- Creditworthiness is a liquidity topic, not a sales topic. A buyer whose financing collapses in the third construction stage tears the chain apart exactly where the most capital is tied up, see Buyers failing on financing.
- The bank’s pre-sales status and your instalment chain are two different things. The bank checks a rate on a reference date. You need the inflow continuously. A met pre-sales rate says nothing about whether the instalments flow.
- Legal obstacles to sale push everything back. Where a conversion ordinance under § 250 BauGB applies or a long protection period against termination is running, the individual sale is delayed, and with it the start of each individual schedule. You will find the status by state and city in the register on conversion and protection periods.
What happens in case of breaches
The MaBV is not a regulation without teeth. Two provisions ensure that breaches are noticed.
§ 16 MaBV: the annual audit. The trader must have compliance with the obligations under §§ 2 to 14 audited for each calendar year at their own cost by a suitable auditor: public auditors, sworn auditors or audit associations. The report goes to the competent authority by 31 December of the following year at the latest; the authority can order extraordinary audits 7.
§ 18 MaBV: administrative offences. The provision lists a series of offences, including the acceptance of assets before the security obligations are met, breaches of § 3, misuse of assets accepted, breach of account separation and missing, incorrect or late records and audit reports 8.
On top of this comes the trade-law level: development activity requires a licence under § 34c GewO (German trade licence for loan brokerage and development activity), and reliability is a condition of the licence 9. Repeated breaches are therefore not a fine topic but an existence topic.
The checklist before the first notary appointment
- The bank’s release declaration is in place and its wording has been checked, including the question of what applies if the project fails.
- The priority notice of conveyance is prepared ready for registration, not merely applied for.
- The building permit is in place or the right to build is confirmed.
- The payment plan has been reconciled against § 3 para. 2 MaBV, rate by rate, and the combination into at most seven instalments is formed cleanly.
- The 5 percent under § 650m para. 2 BGB is included in the liquidity plan and not overlooked.
- If a guarantee solution: guarantee line in place, guarantor permissible under § 2 MaBV, term until full completion.
- If an institutional buyer: merchant status evidenced by register extract, waiver declaration prepared as a separate deed.
- Sales planning laid against the instalment chain: which construction stage needs how many notarised buyers for the liquidity to carry?
Frequently asked questions
Sources
- [1]§ 650u BGB: developer contract, applicable law and exceptions https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/bgb/__650u.html
- [2]§ 650v BGB: instalment payments only under a regulation pursuant to Article 244 EGBGB https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/bgb/__650v.html
- [3]§ 3 MaBV: special security obligations for property developers, instalment schedule https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/gewo_34cdv/__3.html
- [4]§ 650m BGB: instalment payments and security in the consumer construction contract https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/bgb/__650m.html
- [5]§ 7 MaBV: exemption provision: security and waiver by merchants https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/gewo_34cdv/__7.html
- [6]§ 2 MaBV: security and permissible guarantors https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/gewo_34cdv/__2.html
- [7]§ 16 MaBV: audit obligation and reporting deadline https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/gewo_34cdv/__16.html
- [8]§ 18 MaBV: administrative offences https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/gewo_34cdv/__18.html
- [9]§ 34c GewO: licence requirement for property developers and construction supervisors https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/gewo/__34c.html
The instalment schedule holds only as long as the buyers hold.
We obtain creditworthiness-checked buyers on mandate for your residential units and hand them over documented to your sales team. The sales conversation, negotiation and notary appointment stay with you. Because creditworthiness is checked beforehand, fewer appointments fall through and the instalment chain stays intact.
View the unit sales mandate