Which collateral actually holds its value
The question is almost always asked wrongly
The usual question is: is there collateral? It is worthless, because the answer is almost always yes. The right question is: what amount reaches me if everything goes wrong, after deducting what is served before me? Only this question can be calculated.
The difference is not one of wording. A land charge of €1.5 million is collateral of €1.5 million only if €1.5 million is still left after the prior rights. If that is not the case, the deed states an amount that does not exist.
Rank decides, not the deed
In a foreclosure auction, the proceeds are distributed according to the rank classes of § 10 ZVG 1. Ahead of all land charges and mortgages are, among other things, the costs of the proceedings and certain public charges. Only after that come the registered rights, in the order of their rank position. Whoever is in second place gets what is left after the first, no more.
Insolvency has its own order. Whoever holds a land charge or mortgage is in principle entitled to separate satisfaction (absonderungsberechtigt) and is satisfied first from the realisation proceeds 3. Whoever by contrast has only a contractual claim with contractual subordination falls under § 39 InsO and is served only after all other insolvency creditors 2, so in practice almost never.
Assumed: 75 percent of a market value of €8.0 million.
- Costs of proceedings and prior charges300,000 €
- Bank’s first-ranking land charge4,800,000 €
- Second-ranking land charge of the subordinated capital1,500,000 €
- Assumed auction proceeds6,000,000 €
Of the subordinated claim of €1.5 million, €900,000 is covered and €600,000 is lost, although the land charge is registered in full. All figures are assumed and serve illustration only.
Own presentation based on the ranking order of § 10 ZVG · Obermeier Capital
Two provisions soften the picture, but only at the first hearing. Under § 74a Abs. 1 ZVG, a holder whose claim is not covered can apply for the award to be refused if the highest bid stays below seven tenths of the property value 6. Under § 85a Abs. 1 ZVG, the award must be refused if the highest bid does not reach half of the property value 7. At the second hearing neither threshold applies any more.
The land charge: strong, but only in the right place
The land charge (Grundschuld) encumbers the property with the payment of a specific sum of money (§ 1191 BGB) 4; the creditor is satisfied by enforcement against the property (§ 1147 BGB) 5. It is the most resilient of the usual forms of collateral, provided it sits at a rank position that is still covered by the proceeds.
- Check the rank position, not the amount. A current land register extract shows what stands ahead of you.
- Check the outstanding balance of the prior rights. A registered bank land charge of five million may still be drawn at five million or at only one million; the difference decides your coverage.
- Check whether a claim for reassignment (Rückgewähransprucherklärung) has been assigned. Without it you do not benefit when the prior land charge is paid down.
- Check the submission to immediate enforcement (Zwangsvollstreckungsunterwerfung). Without it you first need an enforceable title, and that costs months.
- Check the market value independently. The value stated by the capital seeker is an offer for discussion, not a finding.
The surety: the question is who stands surety
With a surety (Bürgschaft), the surety provider undertakes towards the creditor to answer for the liability of a third party (§ 765 BGB) 8. Its practical value depends on two points, both of which are readily overlooked: the creditworthiness of the surety provider and the design.
In principle the surety provider can refuse payment as long as the creditor has not unsuccessfully enforced against the principal debtor: the defence of prior recourse (Einrede der Vorausklage) under § 771 BGB 9. This defence falls away, among other cases, with a surety as primary obligor (selbstschuldnerische Bürgschaft, § 773 BGB) 10. The difference decides whether in the worst case you can claim against the surety provider immediately or only after a failed enforcement attempt.
The letter of comfort: hard or soft
The letter of comfort (Patronatserklärung) is not regulated by statute; its effect follows solely from the wording. A distinction is drawn between the hard and the soft form, and the difference is as large as between a commitment and an opinion.
- Hard: the parent company undertakes in a legally binding way to provide the subsidiary with enough funds to meet its liabilities. That is enforceable in court.
- Soft: the parent company declares that it knows of the participation, supports it or intends to hold it. No enforceable payment obligation follows from this.
Documents mostly contain the soft form, worded to sound like more. Read the sentence and ask yourself whether you would go to court with it. If not, it is not collateral but a declaration of intent.
The pledge of company shares
A right can also be the subject of a pledge (§ 1273 BGB) 11; it is created under the rules that apply to the transfer of that right (§ 1274 BGB) 12. For GmbH shares this means notarial form. What you get is, in the worst case, access to the company, not to the property.
The value of a pledged share is the value of the company after deduction of its liabilities. For a project company whose property is fully encumbered, this value can be zero in enforcement. The pledge is useful anyway: it gives you influence before it comes to that, such as the right to replace the management.
The assignment of purchase price claims
A claim can be transferred to another person by contract (§ 398 BGB) 13. In unit sales this means: the purchase price claims against the buyers are assigned to the capital provider, and the proceeds flow directly to it. In practice this is often the most effective collateral of all, because it works before any enforcement is needed at all.
- Is the assignment disclosed or silent? A silent assignment helps little if the buyer keeps paying the developer.
- Have the claims already arisen or only in future? Without purchase contracts there is nothing to assign.
- Have the same claims already been assigned to the financing bank? Then you rank behind here as well.
- How does the instalment scale under § 3 MaBV (German developer escrow and instalment regulation) work? It determines when payment is made at all; details are in the article on instalments and sureties.
Subordination is not collateral
In offers for subordinated capital, qualified subordination (qualifizierter Rangrücktritt) is occasionally listed among the terms as if it were a feature of the product like an interest rate. It is the opposite of collateral: it worsens your position because it puts you behind all other creditors and allows the debtor to suspend payments without insolvency having occurred.
That is not bad per se; it is exactly what the higher interest rate is paid for. It is only important to classify it correctly. The mechanics behind it are in the article Understanding subordinated loans, and the question of price in the article why twelve percent is not free money.
The collateral compared
| Collateral | Works against | What matters | Typical weakness |
|---|---|---|---|
| First-ranking land charge | Property value | Rank position and market value | rarely available, usually held by the bank |
| Second-ranking land charge | Property value | Outstanding balance of the prior rights | often not covered on the numbers |
| Surety as primary obligor | Assets of the surety provider | Creditworthiness and independence of the surety provider | surety provider depends on the same project |
| Hard letter of comfort | Assets of the parent | Wording of the obligation | in practice mostly worded softly |
| Pledge of shares | Company | Substance after deduction of debts | share can be worth zero |
| Assignment of claims | Payment stream | Disclosure and priority | often already assigned to the bank |
| Subordination | nothing | none | is not collateral but its opposite |
The checklist before commitment
- Is there a land register extract no older than four weeks?
- Which rights stand in Section III ahead of you, and at what amount are they drawn today?
- Is the market value determined independently or stated by the capital seeker?
- How much is left on the numbers if the property is realised at seventy percent of market value?
- Is the claim for reassignment of the prior land charge assigned to you?
- Is there a submission to immediate enforcement?
- Who is the surety provider, and are their assets independent of the project?
- Is the surety one as primary obligor?
- Is the letter of comfort worded hard and enforceable?
- Are purchase price claims assigned, disclosed and not already granted with priority?
- Does the contract say when you receive which information, and what happens if it does not come?
- Have you worked through the enforcement case once, rather than only reading it?
The one sentence that decides everything
Do not ask which collateral is granted. Ask which amount reaches you if the property is realised at seventy percent of market value. Whoever can name this figure straight away has understood the risk. Whoever cannot or will not name it has not calculated it, and then you calculate it yourself before you subscribe.
Frequently asked questions
Sources
- [1]§ 10 ZVG: rank classes in the distribution of auction proceeds https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/zvg/__10.html
- [2]§ 39 InsO: subordinated insolvency claims https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/inso/__39.html
- [3]§ 51 InsO: other creditors entitled to separate satisfaction https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/inso/__51.html
- [4]§ 1191 BGB: statutory content of the land charge https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/bgb/__1191.html
- [5]§ 1147 BGB: satisfaction by enforcement https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/bgb/__1147.html
- [6]§ 74a ZVG: refusal of the award below seven tenths https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/zvg/__74a.html
- [7]§ 85a ZVG: refusal of the award below one half https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/zvg/__85a.html
- [8]§ 765 BGB: typical contractual duties of a surety https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/bgb/__765.html
- [9]§ 771 BGB: defence of prior recourse https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/bgb/__771.html
- [10]§ 773 BGB: exclusion of the defence of prior recourse https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/bgb/__773.html
- [11]§ 1273 BGB: statutory content of a pledge of rights https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/bgb/__1273.html
- [12]§ 1274 BGB: creation of a pledge of rights https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/bgb/__1274.html
- [13]§ 398 BGB: assignment of a claim https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/bgb/__398.html
Calculate the enforcement case before you subscribe.
We source against your acquisition profile and present pre-screened opportunities, including ranking, outstanding balance and open points. No investment advice.
View acquisition mandate