Why twelve percent is not free money: what the interest rate reveals about risk (2026)
First the most important point: the interest rate is a price tag, not an opportunity
Anyone who is handed an offer at twelve percent first thinks: someone has good access here. The second, correct thought is: why does this project have to pay so much? An interest rate does not arise from generosity. It is the price a capital seeker has to name so that someone is found who bears the risk.
With subordinated capital this risk can be named concretely: the capital provider stands behind the financing bank. If it goes wrong, the capital provider is served as a subordinated insolvency creditor under § 39 InsO only once all prior claims have been satisfied 5, which in practice often means not at all.
Where twelve percent comes from: the rank
The bank finances in first rank, with collateral registered in the land register, at a comparatively low interest rate. Everything needed beyond that must come from a worse position and is paid for accordingly. The typical construction for a subordinated loan is qualified subordination (qualifizierter Rangrücktritt): the investor steps back behind other creditors so that the claim does not have to be counted in the over-indebtedness test under § 19 InsO 6.
- Subordination is not a formality. It turns a claim into something economically closer to equity than to a loan.
- Collateral in the land register mostly sits with the bank. What is registered as subordinated takes effect only when the proceeds exceed the prior rights.
- The interest rate says nothing about probability. It only says how the capital seeker assesses the market, and how urgent the need is.
- Risk, honestly: with subordinated structures the loss is as a rule not a partial loss but a total loss; this structure hardly knows intermediate steps 910.
How rank, collateral and order of default behave in detail is set out in Understanding subordinated loans. The opposite position, first-ranking with collateral at a lower coupon, is covered in Whole loan instead of subordinated.
The market context 2026: why this matters right now
In 2025 the German local courts registered 24,064 applications for corporate insolvency, 10.3 percent more than the previous year 1. With 104 insolvencies per 10,000 companies, construction ranked third among all sectors, behind transport and storage and hospitality 1.
In the first half of 2026 the trend continued: an increase of 4.5 percent in construction. Creditreform warns that the peak has not yet been reached and that the situation is unlikely to stabilise before 2027 at the earliest 34.
The honest calculation: what default rate is in twelve percent
The assumptions are stated openly: a one-year view, a complete loss of the capital invested on default with no enforcement proceeds, and a first-ranking investment at four percent as the benchmark. Simplified, but in exactly the order of magnitude one should have in mind before subscribing.
Seven percent default probability sounds high until you set it beside a sector in which insolvency numbers have been rising for two years in a row. The point is not that twelve percent would be too little. The point is that the figure alone carries no statement; it becomes one only when you set a default assumption against it and check whether the specific project lies below or above it.
| Assumed default rate p.a. | Expected value at 12 % subordinated | Assessment |
|---|---|---|
| 0 percent | plus 12.0 percent | theoretical ideal case, does not exist |
| 3 percent | plus 8.6 percent | clearly better than first-ranking, plausible with very good substance |
| 7.1 percent | plus 4.0 percent | level with a four percent first-ranking investment |
| 10.7 percent | 0 percent | capital works without return |
| 15 percent | minus 5.2 percent | structurally loss-making |
The language by which you recognise it
Where the figure does not convince on its own, language helps out. It is therefore worth reading documents once for their wording alone, regardless of content.
- “Safe” and “secured” are used interchangeably. Two different things: one is an assessment, the other a legal relationship with rank and order.
- “Guaranteed return” on an entrepreneurial participation. Whoever guarantees must be identifiable and have substance of their own, otherwise the guarantee is not worth the paper.
- The warning is missing. § 12 VermAnlG (German Capital Investments Act) requires, when advertising capital investments, a clearly highlighted warning of the risk of total loss 7.
- Return large, rank small. If the interest rate is on page one and the word “subordination” on page fourteen, that is a decision, not carelessness.
- Comparisons with overnight deposits or bonds. Anyone who sets two investments of completely different rank side by side may act in a misleading way within the meaning of § 5 UWG (German Unfair Competition Act) 8.
Which licence must stand behind an offer and what a missing prospectus means is set out in Reputable or grey capital intermediation.
When twelve percent is priced correctly
It would be wrong to conclude from all this that double-digit interest rates are disreputable per se. They are the normal price for subordinated capital in a market in which banks have lowered their loan-to-value; the regulatory reasons are set out in The refinancing gap 2026.
- The project margin demonstrably carries the interest. Not narrowly, but with a buffer for construction delay and price decline.
- The rank is regulated in writing and unambiguously, including the question of what happens in which order on enforcement.
- There is a robust exit, not just a declaration of intent: sale, follow-on financing or enforcement with a realistic valuation.
- The capital seeker has own money at risk. Whoever loses nothing themselves decides differently.
- You diversify. A single participation is not an asset class but a bet; the framework is set out in Mezzanine as an asset class.
The checklist before subscription
- Translate the interest rate into a default assumption. What rate would have to occur for this offer to be worse than a first-ranking alternative?
- Have the rank confirmed in writing, including the subordination declaration and the land register situation.
- Ask about the capital seeker’s equity. Amount, origin and whether it is actually at risk.
- Recalculate the exit, do not just read it, with a scenario in which the sale takes place twelve months later and five percent lower.
- Form a net-of-tax view. In private assets twelve percent gross becomes around nine percent net; the framework is set out in Private debt and tax.
- Plan the diversification before you subscribe the first ticket.
The right question is therefore not: are twelve percent too good to be true? It is: what default probability does this price assume, and do I consider this project better or worse than that assumption?
Frequently asked questions
Sources
- [1]Federal Statistical Office (Statistisches Bundesamt): corporate insolvencies in 2025, +10.3 % on the previous year https://www.destatis.de/DE/Presse/Pressemitteilungen/2026/03/PD26_085_52411.html
- [2]Federal Statistical Office (Statistisches Bundesamt): regular insolvencies applied for in December 2025 https://www.destatis.de/DE/Presse/Pressemitteilungen/2026/01/PD26_012_52411.html
- [3]Creditreform: insolvencies in Germany, first half of 2026 https://www.creditreform.de/aktuelles-wissen/pressemeldungen-fachbeitraege/news-details/show/insolvenzen-in-deutschland-1-halbjahr-2026
- [4]Creditreform: insolvencies in Germany, year 2025 https://www.creditreform.de/aktuelles-wissen/pressemeldungen-fachbeitraege/news-details/show/insolvenzen-in-deutschland-jahr-2025
- [5]§ 39 InsO: subordinated insolvency creditors https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/inso/__39.html
- [6]§ 19 InsO: over-indebtedness https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/inso/__19.html
- [7]§ 12 VermAnlG: advertising for capital investments and warning https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/vermanlg/__12.html
- [8]§ 5 UWG: misleading commercial practices https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/uwg_2004/__5.html
- [9]anwalt.de: real estate crowdinvesting, fixed-interest, safe and now at risk? https://www.anwalt.de/rechtstipps/immobilien-crowdinvesting-festverzinslich-sicher-und-jetzt-gefaehrdet-263964.html
- [10]AKH-H Rechtsanwälte: real estate crowdinvesting and subordinated loans https://akh-h.de/schwerpunkt/crowdinvesting-immobilien/
- [11]Insolvenz-Radar: insolvencies in the construction industry by federal state https://insolvenz-radar.de/statistiken/insolvenzen-baubranche/
A figure is not yet a review.
We source on a mandate basis against your written acquisition profile and present pre-screened opportunities with ranking, collateral, exit scenario and open points. We expressly do not provide investment advice.
View acquisition mandate