Reputable or grey-market capital intermediation: § 34f, liability umbrella and prospectus duty in practice (2026)
First things first: a licence says what someone may do, not how good they are
The market for capital intermediation is hard to read, because the same business card can describe five very different roles. One makes a contact and disappears. Another advises on the investment and is liable for it. A third works under someone else’s licence. A fourth is supervised themselves. And the fifth has nothing at all, and only comes to notice when something goes wrong.
A licence is not a seal of quality. It only says which activity someone may carry out and who is liable if damage occurs. That is exactly why it is the first question, not the last, on both sides of the table: for the developer to whom someone promises capital, and for the capital provider to whom someone presents a participation.
The four licences and what each one covers
Which licence is needed depends not on the title on the website but on the activity actually carried out. The four routes at a glance.
| Role | Legal basis | Covers | Supervision |
|---|---|---|---|
| Loan intermediary (Darlehensvermittler) | § 34c Abs. 1 Nr. 2 GewO | Brokering loans | Trade office and chamber of commerce (IHK) |
| Financial investment intermediary (Finanzanlagenvermittler) | § 34f GewO | Fund units, asset investments (Vermögensanlagen) | Trade office, registration in the intermediary register |
| Tied agent (vertraglich gebundener Vermittler) | § 2 Abs. 10 KWG or § 3 Abs. 2 WpIG (German Securities Institutions Act) | Investment brokerage and advice under another party’s liability | BaFin (German Federal Financial Supervisory Authority) via the liability umbrella |
| Institution with full licence | § 32 KWG | Own securities or banking business | BaFin directly |
| Tippgeber (referrer) | none, licence-exempt | Merely naming opportunities and making contacts | none, as long as the boundary is respected |
For pure investment brokerage, the small licence under § 34f GewO is sufficient in many constellations 1. BaFin has also confirmed that the sector exemption in § 2 Abs. 6 Satz 1 Nr. 8 KWG applies to financial investment intermediaries who forward client orders within an intermediary chain 9.
The Tippgeber: where the boundary really runs
A Tippgeber is someone who carries out an activity directed exclusively at naming opportunities to conclude a contract or at making contacts between a potential client and a licensed intermediary or provider 78. This activity is licence-exempt.
The point is how narrow this definition is. As soon as someone explains the investment, compares advantages and disadvantages, hands over and comments on documents, or works towards the decision, the Tippgeber role ends, regardless of what the contract says. The strict distinction is also relevant under civil law because of the considerable liability risks 8.
- Licence-exempt remains: naming a provider, making a contact, initiating a conversation.
- A licence becomes necessary as soon as someone advises, assesses, recommends or works towards a conclusion.
- The label in the contract does not decide. What counts is what is actually done, in case of doubt reconstructed from emails, presentations and witness statements.
- Risk, honestly: anyone who calls themselves a Tippgeber and in fact advises has no licence, no liability insurance, and in the event of damage has both problems at once.
The liability umbrella (Haftungsdach): the shortcut and its price
Tied agents provide investment brokerage, investment advice or placement business exclusively in the name and for the account of a credit or securities institution. They fall under the exemption in § 2 Abs. 10 KWG or § 3 Abs. 2 WpIG and therefore need no licence of their own 56.
BaFin keeps a public register for this in which anyone can check who is registered under which liability umbrella 5. It is the fastest check you can make at all, and it takes two minutes.
- Advantage: access to business that would not be possible without a licence, without an institution of one’s own.
- Price: the liability umbrella selects, monitors and collects a fee for it, and the choice of products is restricted.
- Supervisory consequence: if a liability umbrella breaches its selection, monitoring or register obligations, BaFin can prohibit it from taking on further tied agents 5.
- Disadvantage, honestly: the tie is exclusive. Changing the umbrella changes the register number and is not a routine administrative step.
Prospectus requirement: when a prospectus may be missing
Anyone who publicly offers asset investments (Vermögensanlagen) in Germany must publish a sales prospectus under § 6 VermAnlG (German Asset Investment Act) 11. That is the principle. The practically relevant exemptions are in § 2 and § 2a VermAnlG 1213.
- Minimum ticket from EUR 200,000 per investor. Offers in which the price per asset investment reaches this threshold are exempt from the prospectus requirement; the legislator assumes a different group of investors here 12.
- Small offers under § 2 VermAnlG. For these cases it must be expressly stated that there is no prospectus requirement 12.
- Crowd financing under § 2a VermAnlG. Central parts of the Act do not apply if the sales price of all asset investments offered by the same issuer within twelve months does not exceed EUR 6 million 13.
- In the exempt cases the VIB takes the place of the prospectus. The Vermögensanlagen-Informationsblatt (asset investment information sheet) must be filed with BaFin and published 1314.
There is also the advertising rule: § 12 VermAnlG requires a clearly highlighted warning of the risk of total loss in advertising for asset investments 15. Anyone who advertises an asset investment without including this warning either has an exemption behind them, or a problem.
What is actually said, and what it means
| Statement in the conversation | What it means under supervisory law | What you should do |
|---|---|---|
| We are only Tippgeber, but happy to advise | Contradiction in itself, advice requires a licence | Ask to see the licence or register entry |
| We work under a liability umbrella | Verifiable in the BaFin register | Ask for the name of the umbrella and the register number |
| We do not need a prospectus here | Possible, but requires a justification | Ask for the specific exemption provision |
| We are only paid on success | Permitted, but creates the wrong incentives | Ask who pays for the preliminary review |
| The investment is secured and safe | Advertising claim, regularly untrue for subordinated ranking | Request ranking and collateral in writing |
| The return is guaranteed | Cannot be presented for an entrepreneurial participation | End the conversation or have the guarantor named |
The last two rows are the most common and the most dangerous. Why a double-digit interest rate on subordinated ranking has nothing to do with safety is worked through in the article Why twelve percent is not free money; the question of ranking is put in context by Understanding subordinated loans.
The honest calculation: why pure success-based remuneration kills the review
The most important difference between careful and grey-market intermediation is not the licence. It is the remuneration model, because it decides whether reviewing is paid for at all. The assumptions are stated openly: three percent success fee on EUR 2 million of placed volume; a serious preliminary review covering calculation, land register, ranking and exit takes four working days.
This is not a moral argument but an arithmetic one. Anyone paid exclusively on success has an economic incentive against rejection, and rejection is the most valuable part of the work. That is why the question of who pays for the preliminary review is more telling than any reference list.
The checklist for the first conversation
- Ask for the licence and for the number. § 34c, § 34f, liability umbrella or § 32 KWG: one of them must be nameable.
- Check the BaFin register. For tied agents the entry is public and checked in two minutes.
- Have the role recorded in writing. Tippgeber, intermediary or adviser, with the consequences for liability and documentation.
- For asset investments, clarify the prospectus status. Prospectus, VIB or exemption, with the provision named.
- Have the remuneration model disclosed. Who pays what, to whom, when and for what, including payments from the other side.
- Ask for the rejection rate. Anyone who has never rejected a project does not review.
The right question is therefore not: does my counterpart have a licence? But: is he paid for saying no, and can he name the provision under which he works?
Frequently asked questions
Sources
- [1]§ 34f GewO: Financial investment intermediary (Gesetze im Internet) https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/gewo/__34f.html
- [2]§ 34c GewO: Estate agents, property developers, construction supervisors, loan intermediaries https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/gewo/__34c.html
- [3]§ 32 KWG: Licence https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/kredwg/__32.html
- [4]§ 54 KWG: Prohibited business, acting without a licence https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/kredwg/__54.html
- [5]BaFin: Register of tied agents https://www.bafin.de/DE/die-bafin/publikationen-daten/datenbanken-uebersichten/vermittler/vermittler_node.html
- [6]IHK Aachen: Tied agent under § 2 Absatz 10 Satz 1 KWG https://www.ihk.de/aachen/zielgruppen/unternehmen/branchen/finanzdienstleister/vertraglich-gebundener-vermittler-598404
- [7]Prof. Dr. Thomas Zacher: The Tippgeber (PDF) https://zacherlegal.de/wp-content/uploads/2021/09/Der-Tippgeber.pdf
- [8]DFPA: Distinguishing Tippgeber models from advice and brokerage https://www.dfpa.info/proberater-news/artikel/abgrenzung-von-tippgebermodellen-von-beratung-vermittlung-summary-die-strenge-abgrenzung-zwischen-der-taetigkeit-als-sog-tippgeber-einerseits-und-der-betaetigung-als-anlagevermittler-berater-andererseits-ist-bereits-aufgrund-der-erheblichen-haftungsris.html
- [9]CMS: BaFin on the intermediary chain: a licence under § 34f GewO is sufficient https://cms.law/de/deu/publication/bafin-schmiert-die-vermittlerkette-fuer-alle-vermittler-genuegt-die-erlaubnis-nach-34-f-gewo
- [10]erhard.rechtsanwälte: Unlicensed conduct of banking business (§ 54 KWG) https://rechtsanwalt-erhard.de/unerlaubtes-betreiben-von-bankgeschaeften-%C2%A7-54-kwg-strafbarkeit-ohne-bafin-erlaubnis-typische-fallen-bei-darlehen-crowdfunding-krypto/
- [11]§ 6 VermAnlG: Obligation to publish a sales prospectus https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/vermanlg/__6.html
- [12]§ 2 VermAnlG: Exemptions from the prospectus requirement https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/vermanlg/__2.html
- [13]§ 2a VermAnlG: Exemptions for crowd financing https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/vermanlg/__2a.html
- [14]BaFin: Prospectus requirement for asset investments: overview of the procedure https://www.bafin.de/DE/Aufsicht/Prospekte/Vermoegensanlagen/Prospektpflicht/Prospektpflicht_node.html
- [15]§ 12 VermAnlG: Advertising for asset investments and warning notice https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/vermanlg/__12.html
Reviewing is work. So it is paid for.
We work on a mandate and fee basis: first we review calculation, ranking, collateral and exit, and only then do we raise capital. What does not hold up does not go out. We expressly do not provide investment advice.
How we work