The video only loads from YouTube after you click. No investment advice, no return promises.
01
What a forward deal is
A forward deal is the sale of a development project before it is finished. The purchase contract is concluded while the building is still being built, often even before the first excavator arrives, and in some cases before planning permission has been granted. The buyer thus acquires not a property but a promise: that on a certain date a certain building of a certain quality will stand there.
For the developer this solves a problem bigger than the price: he knows where the project is going before he has carried the risk to the end. For the institutional buyer it solves a different one: he gets new build without competing against five other bidders, and can have a say in specification and floor plans while that is still possible.
The difference lies in payment, not in the contract
Both variants, forward purchase and forward funding, have in common that the purchase contract is concluded before completion. That is not the distinguishing feature. The distinction is made by the point at which the purchase price flows 12.
Feature
Forward purchase
Forward funding
Payment of the purchase price
in full on handover
in instalments according to construction progress
Who finances the construction
the developer
predominantly the buyer
Price level
higher, because financing costs are priced in
lower, because the buyer takes over the financing
Risk for the buyer
limited until handover
in the project from the first instalment
Risk for the developer
carries the interim financing to the end
considerably relieved
Typical motivation
planning certainty on the exit
return premium in exchange for taking on construction risk
Scroll table sideways
02
Why the MaBV decides what is possible at all
This is the point at which most conversations tip, and one that many notice only when the notary reads the draft. A developer may not simply accept money from his client by agreement. The Makler- und Bauträgerverordnung (MaBV, German developer escrow and instalment regulation) prescribes when and how much he may take.
Under § 3 Abs. 1 MaBV he may collect anything at all only once four things are in place 3:
The contract is legally effective and the necessary permits are in place.
A priority notice for conveyance (Auflassungsvormerkung) securing the claim to transfer of title is registered in the land register.
Release from prior encumbrances is assured, that is, it is clarified that the land charges of the financing bank do not affect the buyer.
The building permit is in place or the right to build is confirmed accordingly.
And even then he may accept the purchase price only in at most seven partial amounts according to construction progress (§ 3 Abs. 2 MaBV) 3. The scale is prescribed: around 30 percent after the start of earthworks (20 percent for leasehold, Erbbaurecht), then 40 percent after the shell is complete, and the rest spread in small steps over the further construction stages up to completion.
A forward funding with a freely negotiated payment plan therefore cannot be shown within the scope of the MaBV. Anyone who tries anyway risks more than invalidity of the clause: a payment plan that deviates from the MaBV to the buyer’s detriment can be invalid as a whole and is then replaced by the statutory default rule, with the result that the remuneration falls due only on acceptance.
The exception that makes institutional deals possible at all
§ 7 MaBV knows two ways out. The first, paragraph 1: the developer provides security for the client’s claims, in practice a bank surety (Bankbürgschaft), and is thereby free from the constraints of §§ 2 to 6. The security must remain in place until full completion 4.
The second, paragraph 2, is the one decisive for forward deals: the constraints fall away if the client is a legal entity under public law, a special fund under public law or a merchant entered in the commercial or cooperative register, and waives their application in a separate document 4.
03
What the developer gains, and what it costs him
The exit is in place before the risk has been carried to the end. That is the real value. A project with a buyer in place is a different conversation at the bank than one without.
With forward funding, the debt requirement falls considerably. The buyer pays along while construction is under way, which replaces interim financing and relieves the equity ratio.
The price is lower than with individual sales. An institutional buyer buys as a package and prices in a discount. Anyone who can see the division through generally earns more selling individually; run the numbers in the condo conversion calculator.
Freedom in the project falls. Building specification, fit-out standard and dates are contractually fixed from signing. Changes need the buyer’s consent.
Overrunning the deadline becomes expensive. Delays in forward contracts regularly carry contractual penalties, often graduated and, beyond a certain duration, a right of withdrawal.
04
What the buyer gains, and what he bears
Access without a bidding process. The biggest advantage is not the price but that there is anything to buy at all.
A say while it still costs little. Floor plans, fit-out and technical equipment can be influenced early, and not at all with an existing property.
A return premium in exchange for taking on risk. With forward funding the buyer pays during construction without income; in return he buys more cheaply than at completion.
Completion risk. If completion does not happen, the buyer has already paid and has a construction site. What applies then is decided solely by the contract.
Insolvency risk at the developer. That is the risk the MaBV protections are meant to absorb for consumers, and which the institutional buyer has knowingly waived.
Letting risk, if no rental income undertaking (Mietgarantie) has been agreed. For properties that are not fully let, the question belongs in the contract, not in the calculation.
05
The contract building blocks on which it fails
With an existing purchase you check what is there. With a forward deal you check what is to be, and that is found exclusively in the contract. Six points on which negotiations get stuck in practice:
Building specification and quality standard. The actual object of purchase. Anything left undefined here is later interpreted against the one who did not write it.
Completion date, penalty and right of withdrawal. From what delay does which consequence apply? A date without a sanction is a declaration of intent.
Acceptance. Who accepts, under what procedure, and what happens with defects? With forward funding the final payment regularly depends on acceptance.
Collateral. Performance, completion and warranty sureties: at what amount, from which bank, with what term?
Purchase price adjustment. What happens with more or less area, with changes in rental income, with special requests? Without a mechanism every deviation becomes a dispute.
Insolvency resistance of the structure. What happens to instalments already paid if the developer defaults? Priority notice, release declaration and sureties must interlock; individually they help little.
06
When which variant pays off
The choice between purchase and funding is at its core a financing decision. It depends on who gets money more cheaply, and who is prepared to bear risk for it.
Starting position
Suitable structure
Reason
Developer has cheap bank financing and wants to maximise price
Forward purchase
The interim financing is cheaper than the discount a funding costs
Developer gets no interim financing or only expensive interim financing
Forward funding
The buyer replaces the bank; that can be cheaper than mezzanine
Buyer wants maximum return and can bear construction risk
Forward funding
The entry price falls, the risk rises accordingly
Buyer may not bear construction risk under its own investment terms
Forward purchase
Payment only on handover, hence limited advance performance risk
Buyer is a consumer
neither of the two
The MaBV instalment scale applies mandatorily; a free payment plan is excluded
Scroll table sideways
07
What goes wrong in practice
The date slips. The most common case and the one for which there are the clearest contract mechanisms, if they have been written in.
Construction costs run away. With a fixed price the developer bears this. That is exactly why forward deals come under pressure in cost phases: the price is fixed, the costs are not.
Letting falls behind. If the purchase price depends on rental income that is not achieved, the adjustment clause decides the difference, or there is none and then you argue.
The developer defaults. The worst case. This shows whether priority notice, release and sureties work together or merely stand next to each other in the contract.
The structure does not fit the buyer. A fund with narrow investment terms may not provide certain advance performance at all. That belongs before the declaration of intent, not in the review; see acquisition profile.
08
How a forward deal comes about
Get the project into shape. Planning permission, calculation with contingency, timetable, letting status or letting assumption, evidenced and not asserted.
Fix the structure. Purchase or funding, and with it: does the buyer come into question as a merchant under § 7 Abs. 2 MaBV, or does the instalment scale remain mandatory?
Approach suitable addresses. Not as many as possible, but those whose acquisition profile the project meets. A no from the wrong profile costs both sides weeks.
Declaration of intent and exclusivity. Anyone who grants exclusivity should receive bindingness for it: deadlines, scope of review, grounds for abandonment.
Acquisition review. Legal, technical, tax, calculation. With a forward deal the contract is the object of review, not the building.
Notarial certification, where applicable with a separate waiver document under § 7 Abs. 2 MaBV.
Construction phase with reporting duties. Construction progress reports, payment releases, access to the site, all agreed beforehand.
Acceptance, final payment, transfer of benefits and burdens.
Sits on both sides of the table in forward structures: with developers who need certainty before completion, and with family offices that want to buy new build without a bidding process.
A forward deal stands or falls with the buyer you find.
For developers: we review calculation, timetable and collateral and then approach specifically the acquisition addresses the project fits. For family offices and funds: we search on a mandate basis against your acquisition profile, pre-screened, instead of offering you whatever happens to be available.