Reading a term sheet: the ten clauses that make the difference
The two halves of a term sheet
A term sheet is short, usually two to four pages, and therefore looks more harmless than it is. What it says is spelled out later in the contract, but it is negotiated here. Anyone who attacks a position only in the contract draft is negotiating against a consensus already reached.
The first half is the one that is talked about: amount, interest, term. The second half decides what happens when things do not go as planned, and that is exactly the half that gets skimmed. This article goes through it clause by clause, from the capital provider’s perspective.
One: rank, not the word but the effect
Almost every mezzanine term sheet names a rank. What matters is which one is meant: the contractual subordination that takes effect in insolvency under § 39 InsO 1, or the rank position of a land charge (Grundschuld) that decides in a foreclosure auction under § 10 ZVG 2. Both can exist independently of each other, and both are rarely stated precisely on paper.
- Is a qualified subordination (qualifizierter Rangrücktritt) provided for, and if so, in what wording?
- At which rank position is a land charge to be registered, and at what amount are the prior rights drawn today?
- Is there a standstill agreement with the senior bank, and what may the subordinated capital provider still do under it?
- Who may enforce first, and from which event?
What each rank actually means in enforcement is worked through in the article which collateral actually holds its value.
Two: drawdown conditions
Between commitment and drawdown lie the conditions. The longer this list, the later the money flows, and the greater the likelihood that a condition is never met. From the capital provider’s perspective a short list is a risk; from the developer’s perspective a long list is a timing problem. Both sides should count them before signing.
Typical conditions are a building permit, registration of the collateral in the land register, submission of the senior financing commitment, evidence of a pre-sales ratio and the appointment of the use-of-proceeds control. Each should carry a date by which it is to be in place.
Three: use of proceeds and control
What the money may be used for, and who checks it. Without use-of-proceeds control, a subordinated loan is a blank cheque to a project company. With control, a commitment becomes a procedure: payout against proof of invoice, release by a third party, construction progress monitoring.
Four: covenants and information rights
Covenants are the early warning. Without them a capital provider learns of trouble when the payment fails to arrive, which is too late. Usual are a minimum pre-sales level, a ceiling for construction cost overruns, a ban on further encumbrances without consent and the duty to report material events without delay.
- Which metrics are reported, at what interval and in what form?
- What counts as a breach, and what follows from it: a cure period, an interest surcharge, a termination right?
- Is there a right of access to the construction site and a right to inspect the books?
- Who bears the cost of an external expert if doubts arise?
Five: termination rights
By statute a lender can terminate extraordinarily if the borrower’s financial position or the value of collateral deteriorates significantly and repayment is thereby endangered (§ 490 Abs. 1 BGB) 4. A qualified subordination can in practice devalue this right, which is why the two have to be read together.
The term sheet should say which events trigger a termination right, whether there are cure periods and what happens on a change of control in the project company. A change of shareholder at the developer changes the capital provider’s risk completely without anything changing in the project.
Six: term, extension and what it costs
Projects take longer than planned; that is the normal case, not the exception. What matters is therefore not the term but the extension clause: is there an option, on what terms, who exercises it and how much does it cost. If it is missing, you negotiate from the weakest conceivable position, namely shortly before maturity.
Seven: early repayment and minimum term
The opposite direction: what happens if the project runs faster than expected? Many structures contain a minimum interest or a prepayment penalty that makes early repayment expensive. For the capital provider this is return protection; for the developer it is a cost trap on a successful sell-down. Both sides should know the figure before they sign.
Eight: exit participation and equity kicker
A participation in the project surplus sounds simple and never is. The questions behind it: based on which surplus, before or after which costs? How is it determined, and by whom? What applies if the project is partly sold and partly held? And when is it paid, on sale or on completion?
How much the kicker raises total costs is worked through in the article what mezzanine capital really costs: a nominal twelve percent becomes around 16.8 percent a year there.
Nine: exclusivity and allocation of costs
Many term sheets contain an exclusivity period: the developer may not negotiate in parallel during the review. That is usual and legitimate, but only in return for something, namely a fixed period and a binding timetable. Exclusivity without an end date is a one-sided commitment.
This includes the allocation of costs: who pays for expert reports, legal advice and valuation if the financing does not come about in the end? This clause decides how expensive a failure becomes, and it is often in the small print.
Ten: what in the term sheet is actually binding
The most important sentence is usually right at the bottom: which parts are binding and which are not. It is usual for the economic key terms to remain non-binding while exclusivity, confidentiality and allocation of costs bind. Anyone who does not read this paragraph believes they have a financing and has a commitment.
The ten clauses at a glance
| Clause | What matters | Typical weakness |
|---|---|---|
| Rank | contractual and land register rank named separately | only the word subordinated, without rank position and outstanding balance |
| Drawdown conditions | complete list with deadlines | open-ended list without end date |
| Use of proceeds | named releasing party and duty of proof | mere earmarking without control |
| Covenants | measurable metrics and reporting duties | soft wording without legal consequence |
| Termination rights | triggers, cure periods, change of control | subordination in effect devalues § 490 BGB |
| Term and extension | option with price fixed in advance | no option, renegotiation under time pressure |
| Early repayment | quantified minimum interest | overlooked until the sell-down runs faster |
| Exit participation | basis of calculation and determination regulated | percentage without a defined basis |
| Exclusivity and costs | fixed period, clear allocation of costs on failure | open-ended commitment, costs with the developer |
| Bindingness | express separation of binding and non-binding | misread as a commitment |
The checklist before signing
- Which rank is meant: contractual, land register or both?
- At what amount are the prior rights drawn today?
- How many drawdown conditions are there, and does each have a date?
- Who releases funds, and against what proof?
- Which metric is reported when, and what follows from a breach?
- Which events trigger a termination right, and are there cure periods?
- What happens on a change of shareholder in the project company?
- Is there an extension option, and is its price already fixed today?
- What does early repayment cost?
- What basis of calculation does the exit participation refer to, and who calculates it?
- How long does the exclusivity last, and who bears the costs on failure?
- Which paragraphs are expressly binding?
The one question that sorts everything
Read the term sheet a second time and ask only one question of each clause: what happens here if the project takes six months longer and becomes ten percent more expensive? Clauses that regulate nothing in this case are the ones you have to negotiate. Everything else is price discussion.
Frequently asked questions
Sources
- [1]§ 39 InsO: subordinated insolvency claims https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/inso/__39.html
- [2]§ 10 ZVG: rank classes in the distribution of auction proceeds https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/zvg/__10.html
- [3]§ 488 BGB: typical contractual duties under a loan agreement https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/bgb/__488.html
- [4]§ 490 BGB: extraordinary termination right https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/bgb/__490.html
- [5]§ 1191 BGB: statutory content of the land charge https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/bgb/__1191.html
- [6]§ 32 KWG: licensing requirement for banking business https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/kredwg/__32.html
- [7]§ 311b BGB: contracts concerning land, notarial certification https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/bgb/__311b.html
Presented pre-screened, including the second half.
We source against your acquisition profile and present with ranking, outstanding balance and open points. No investment advice.
View acquisition mandate