Owner-occupier or buy-to-let investor: addressing 2 buyer groups correctly
Owner-occupier or buy-to-let investor: two buyer groups, two approaches. What this means for let and vacant units.
Watch on YouTubeOwner-occupier or buy-to-let investor: two buyer groups, two approaches. What this means for let and vacant units.
Watch on YouTubeThe video only loads from YouTube after you click. No investment advice, no return promises.
A let condominium fetches less than the same apartment without a tenant. That is undisputed. What is disputed is only whether the route to a vacant sale pays off, and in practice this question is almost never calculated cleanly but decided by feel.
The reason is that on one side there is a large, clearly visible number, the additional proceeds, and on the other side four small, poorly visible ones: compensation, lost rent, interest on the capital tied up for longer and the probability that the tenant stays after all. Only together do they make a decision.
If let residential space is sold, the acquirer takes the landlord’s place in the existing tenancy (§ 566 BGB) 1. The lease continues unchanged, with the same rent, the same periods and the same rights. Whoever buys a let apartment buys the lease with it.
The price difference follows from this. An owner-occupier cannot move into a let apartment and therefore drops out as a buyer. What remains are buy-to-let investors who calculate by yield, and whose willingness to pay depends on the rent, not on the price per square metre for owner-occupiers.
If condominium ownership was created on let residential space after it was handed over to the tenant and this was sold, an acquirer can rely on own-use need or termination for economic exploitation only after three years have passed since the sale (§ 577a para. 1 BGB) 4. In areas with particularly endangered housing supply, the federal states can extend this period by ordinance to up to ten years (§ 577a para. 2 BGB) 4.
Less well known is paragraph 1a: the restriction applies accordingly if let residential space is sold to a partnership or to several acquirers, even without prior division 4. Whoever tries to circumvent the termination blocking period through a community of acquirers runs into the same period. Which period applies in which federal state and in which city is listed in the register on conversion and termination blocking period.
Regardless of which route you choose: if condominium ownership is created after handover to the tenant and sold to a third party, the tenant has a pre-emption right (§ 577 BGB) 3. The notification must be in writing, the exercise period is two months. If proper notification is omitted, the period does not start to run. The details are in the article on pre-emption right and termination blocking period.
In practice there are not two options but three. The third is most often overlooked, although it is usually the most economically sensible.
Let us calculate it. All assumptions are stated openly so that you can replace them with your own, especially as the price gap between let and vacant depends heavily on location and property.
EUR 380,000 vacant versus EUR 320,000 let.
Of EUR 60,000 additional proceeds, EUR 15,000 remain after compensation, lost rent and interest, for eight months of waiting and the risk that the tenant does not agree. All values are assumed and serve only for illustration.
Own presentation, assumptions disclosed in the text · Obermeier Capital
From a supposed EUR 60,000 of additional proceeds, EUR 15,000 remain. That can be worthwhile, but it is a different decision from the one you make when looking only at the 60,000. And it is a decision under uncertainty: if the tenant declines, you have lost the eight months anyway.
Three variables decide, and all three can be estimated beforehand.
A fourth variable is rarely included: with a larger property these processes run in parallel, and the unit sales extend across all units. What that means for the overall duration is explained in the article on time to sell in unit sales.
| Criterion | Sell let | Wait for turnover | Move-out against compensation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Proceeds | lower, valued by yield | higher | higher |
| Circle of buyers | only buy-to-let investors | owner-occupiers and investors | owner-occupiers and investors |
| Timing | immediate | completely open | plannable, but not certain |
| Direct costs | none | none | compensation |
| Indirect costs | none | capital tied up without an end date | vacancy and interest |
| Risk | low | tenant stays permanently | tenant declines, time is lost |
| Termination blocking period relevant | yes, for the buyer | no | no |
| Suitable for | large stock, time pressure | long-term holding | large price gap and patience |
Whoever sells let sells to an investor, and their price depends directly on the rent. An adjustment to the local comparative rent under § 558 BGB 5 or a modernisation rent increase under § 559 BGB 6 therefore works twice: on the current income and on the sale price.
Both routes are tied to narrow conditions and periods and should be checked before use. Economically, however, they are often the calmer lever: they raise the price without anyone having to move out, and they do not cost eight months.
Before there is any decision about let or vacant, there is the question whether division is allowed at all. In areas with a tight housing market, the federal states can make the conversion of buildings with more than five residential units subject to a permit (§ 250 BauGB, German Building Code) 7. Whoever asks this question after the acquisition has asked it too late.
Not: how much more do I get vacant? But: from what price gap does the route there pay off at all, given my capital tied up, my realistic duration and my compensation amount? Whoever has calculated this threshold once can then apply it to every unit in seconds, instead of discussing it anew each time.
We source financing-verified buyers for your residential units, let or vacant. Your sales team leads the closing.
View unit sales